Adam McQuaid vs Bobby Robins 1/15/2012 Article and video of fight...

[Tucker_316]

Originally Posted by habsfan1122

mcquaid has never been a hw but he should be and thats the point was trying to make. but obviously his win/loss rate would be different so yeah, he doesnt want to step up of category.

i like the fact that he took on bobby robins here dont get me wrong. he was in his fight-category there... next time he fights a sabre, for exemple, id like to see him fight mccormick instead of kaleta. and when he fights mccormick, actually fight instead of locking him up and wait until cody loses his balance.

He's not good enough to be a legit heavy. He could barely handle Ryan White who has like half a foot difference on him.

[BOSTONMASSACRE]

Originally Posted by Tucker_316

He's not good enough to be a legit heavy. He could barely handle Ryan White who has like half a foot difference on him.

Troll along ya pencil necked geek!
Your teams players don't even want to play for your team anymore and our players, even the ones with concussion issues are fighting for every spot even if that means coming off of a few concussions and scrapping with players from our farm team.
It's called heart.
Lets see how everything turns out in the long run what do you say?
"Pk Subban not close to deal may sit out season".
http://nesn.com/2013/01/report-canad...eason-on-time/
Ill take Adam McQuaid over Pk Subban any day.
I know most will agree.

[habsfan1122]

Originally Posted by BOSTONMASSACRE

Lets see how everything turns out in the long run what do you say?
"Pk Subban not close to deal may sit out season".
http://nesn.com/2013/01/report-canad...eason-on-time/
Ill take Adam McQuaid over Pk Subban any day.
I know most will agree.

its not like im a great fan of subban and neither of the actual product we have on ice

[Tucker_316]

Originally Posted by BOSTONMASSACRE

Troll along ya pencil necked geek!
Your teams players don't even want to play for your team anymore and our players, even the ones with concussion issues are fighting for every spot even if that means coming off of a few concussions and scrapping with players from our farm team.
It's called heart.
Lets see how everything turns out in the long run what do you say?
"Pk Subban not close to deal may sit out season".
http://nesn.com/2013/01/report-canad...eason-on-time/
Ill take Adam McQuaid over Pk Subban any day.
I know most will agree.

Err, how was I trolling exactly? All I said was that Mcquaid isnt good enough of a fighter to be a legit heavy. Am I wrong? There are plenty of reasons and examples as to why, I just listed one. My fellow Habs fan was going on about how he should fight dudes like that all the time. Then you take it to heart because you've got a boner for the guy and wanna such his dick, and rant about PK Subban and ****. You Boston fans are priceless. And Subban is greater than McQ. Neely makes that trade 10 times out of 10, although a GM would have to be stupid to trade PK for only him.

[BOSTONMASSACRE]

Neely would NEVER make that trade and you probably would NEVER understand why.
Like I said McQuaid is coming off of concussion problems, shoulder problems, bloodclot removed, what does he do, he goes out there and fights a legit heavy that's part of his organazation in a scrimmage game!

Subban is a crybaby and a cancer in the locker room, and he won't even show up for practice.
http://nesn.com/2013/01/report-canad...eason-on-time/

Oh and then there's this...
http://search.yahoo.com/search;_ylt=...p&fr=yfp-t-701

Good luck with all that.
Enjoy another great season!

[BOSTONMASSACRE]

Again for everyone else and not just this clown's ass over here...

I think PK is a great player but like I said he is selfish, childish, and has been a cancer to his team.
Too bad, id like too see him with an organazation like Philly, or The Rangers where they could channel the kids energy a little better and keep him in check. Good leaders around him maybe would help.
But for me ill take an Adam McQuaid over PK Subban every day, and I believe most Hockeyfights.com fans would as well.
In the old days it took alot more then just being a talented player, you had to have heart and love the game.
Just my opinion.

[cookie monster]

Originally Posted by BOSTONMASSACRE

Again for everyone else and not just this clown's ass over here...

I think PK is a great player but like I said he is selfish, childish, and has been a cancer to his team.
Too bad, id like too see him with an organazation like Philly, or The Rangers where they could channel the kids energy a little better and keep him in check. Good leaders around him maybe would help.
But for me ill take an Adam McQuaid over PK Subban every day, and I believe most Hockeyfights.com fans would as well.
In the old days it took alot more then just being a talented player, you had to have heart and love the game.
Just my opinion.

I like Adam McQuaid allot and love what he brings to the game, but you're out of your mind if you think Neely wouldn't trade him for Subban.

Subban can grow up he's only 21., McQuaid can't grow offensive talent like Subban has.

If that your opinion, that's fine, but every gm in history would make that trade.

[Cat Smasher]

Originally Posted by cookie monster

If that your opinion, that's fine, but every gm in history would make that trade.

I disagree, but that's because I know McQuaid and Subban personally, also probably why I'm not a GM

I would take a back end full of McQuaid's over Subban right now, any day.

[BOSTONMASSACRE]

Originally Posted by cookie monster

I like Adam McQuaid allot and love what he brings to the game, but you're out of your mind if you think Neely wouldn't trade him for Subban.

Subban can grow up he's only 21., McQuaid can't grow offensive talent like Subban has.

If that your opinion, that's fine, but every gm in history would make that trade.

Again, my opinon but lets ask the Hockeyfights.com members.
Would Cam Neely (Cam Neely we're talking about) trade Adam McQuaid for PK Subban?
Forget who the more talented player is, which I have never debated.
CAM NEELY would trade Adam McQuaid for PK Subban?
lol
And you say "every GM in history would make that trade".
Unfortunately because of thinking like that we are where we are at with this league.
Again, ill take a couple Adam McQuaids over a few PK Subbans any day.
Anyone agree?

[RetardedChimp]

Originally Posted by BOSTONMASSACRE

Like I said McQuaid is coming off of concussion problems, shoulder problems, bloodclot removed, what does he do, he goes out there and fights a legit heavy that's part of his organazation in a scrimmage game!

Robins isn't a legit heavy. He's a middleweight, a LHW at best. Very similar to McQuaid to be honest.

I also agree that even though McQuaid is bigger than most other middleweights, he shouldn't be fighting heavyweights because quite frankly I don't think he would be able to hang with them. I have also noticed that he 'tones it down' if there is an opposing heavy on the ice, so he realizes that as well. It can be irritating to see him 'goon it up' against weaklings, but until someone goes and punks him down why would he stop? It's not a knock against him either, it's just knowing his abilities as a fighter. He's fighting in his weight class, and that is fine.

[Phillyfan11]

Originally Posted by acdcrocksno1

Because you have to wear one in the ahl you dumb ****

You'd think more fans would understand this no?

[brymaster1]

This makes me respect McQuaid a little bit more. He has know reason to fight after coming back from concusion issues, surguey, and it being against a likely career AHLer. Good on you McQuaid

[cookie monster]

Originally Posted by Phillyfan11

You'd think more fans would understand this no?

Understand what?

I know that all AHL players have to wear a visor in AHL games, but this was an "scrimmage" and like I said Lane MCDermid was playing on the Providence Squad and wasn't wearing a visor.

It was a legitimate question..

[cookie monster]

Originally Posted by BOSTONMASSACRE

Again, my opinon but lets ask the Hockeyfights.com members.
Would Cam Neely (Cam Neely we're talking about) trade Adam McQuaid for PK Subban?
Forget who the more talented player is, which I have never debated.
CAM NEELY would trade Adam McQuaid for PK Subban?
lol
And you say "every GM in history would make that trade".
Unfortunately because of thinking like that we are where we are at with this league.
Again, ill take a couple Adam McQuaids over a few PK Subbans any day.
Anyone agree?

You're out of your mind.

Brad Marchand was just as much of a selfish, diving cheap shot artist as Subban, and probably more hated by anyone outside of New England. His rookie year he was benched for throwing a stick during a tantrum on the bench.

The Bruins are patient with him because he's a very good player, scores clutch goals and is a major pain in the ass of his opponents.

PK Subban, who has allot of growing up to do is an extremely talented defenceman that is a worst a number two.

There is no way any GM would say "even up Subban for McQuaid.....No thanks" because Subban is a douche.

Do I think Neely would activity seek to trade for him? No. If Bergivan cashed with that offer, Neely would have to say yes, because talent wise it's not even close.

If someone said Dubinsky for a Sedin straight up, I'd say "um duh do it" but I like and appreciate Dubinskys style over Sedins, it's an obvious no brainer.


If PK Subban was a Bruin you'd love him like Bruins fans love Marchands cheap play.

Neely makes that trade all day long. Subban is not that bad...

[Orr4]

The only team that wouldn't take Subban for McQuaid is Toronto.

If PK came to Boston, Thornton would ride his A$$ until he either shaped up or got traded again.