Who would you take?

[Word]

Originally Posted by Ciccarelli

Haven't seen a topic like that for a long time now so I thought about it:

Jason Spezza or Jeff Carter

Simon Gagne or Phil Kessel

Brandon Coburn or Marc Staal

Mike Richards or Pavel Datsyuk. Youth movement.

Daniel Carcillo or Jared Boll

Dustin Brown or Nathan Horton

Victor Hedman or Eric Johnson

Peter Mueller or David Backes

[The Crow]

Orr vs Godard- I like Orr better and he's a slightly better fighter and player imo
Laraque vs Brashear- Because I think Laraque has more years left, although I'd take Brash for 1.
Boogaard vs Big Mac- Boogaard and his injury troubles...
King vs Shelley- Younger guy who is better in about every single aspect of the game, including fighting.
Parros vs McGrattan- See MacIntyre /Boogaard
Belak vs Ivanans-Ivanans the better player and in my opinion Belak is extremely overrated.
Neil vs Lucic- It's not even close.
Carcillo vs Rypien- Both great mw's but Carcillo is the better player
Prust vs Moen- very tough choice, but moen is the better player and is as good a fighter.
Bissonnette vs Jackman- Biz is younger and a better fighter, even though I dislike him.