[Churla22]

Originally Posted by LAWMAN

I find this to be an interesting quote. Although Biggio had 3000+ hits, his career average is like .280 and he was never a top 5 player in the league in any given year. Classic compiler. Not saying he is not worthy, just don't view him as a great player. And as good as Schilling was in some big games, his career win total for me is too low. You cant let him in and then keep guys like Morris and Mussina out. Piazza is your best argument I think, because for a 5-10 year run, he was the best hitting catcher in baseball.

Biggio also had a Hall of Fame-quality prime.