It seems to me, many people base Brashear's ranking on his style of fighting rather than how many wins he had, and how few loses he did.
I wonder why Probert always gets a free pass for his jersey shedding. Probert had so many fights where his jersey came off, it was borderline ridiculous. Yah, I know in the 80's guys wore goalie shirts, velcro sleeves etc.. Still, before all of that, Probert was jersey shedding big time.
You can flame me all you want, but if you people are going to disregard the jersey shedding (which helped him alot) then you have to disregard Brashear's fighting style.
BTW - I don't personally rank fighters, but will say both are two of the best I have ever witnessed fight in hockey.