I guess I'll throw my 2 cents in even though I'm not a big fan of lists. They are always subjective and tend to end in pointless debate but what the hey, I'll give it a go. I am willing to discuss why I put a certain player where I did in my list but I'm not gonna have a pissing match as to why my list/your list is better, more legit, etc. My criteria was based on # of fights, winning percentage, strength of card and I also took into account in some cases a "prognostic" approach as too how well a fighter would have done if they would have had a longer career. Thats why I have some guys with short careers higher than some lists do. My winning percentages are from DYG so take them for what they are worth. Comments are welcome, insults and a rope to piss up are not.
1)Bob Probert-302 NHL fights 58%
2)Dave Brown-202 NHL fights 62%
3)Behn Wilson-98 NHL fights 63%
4)Donald Brashear-278 NHL fights 60% record vs. Laraque 2w/3d/1l
5)Joey Kocur-262 NHL fights 60%
6)Georges Laraque-153 NHL fights 60%
7)Chris Simon-129 NHL fights 60%
8)Tony Twist-136 NHL fights 61%
9)Larry Playfair-117 NHL fights 63%
10)Jim McKenzie-212 NHL fights 55%
11)Bob Nystrom-139 NHL fights 61%
12)John Kordic-125 NHL fights 60%
13)Clark Gillies-73 NHL fights 60%
14)Tie Domi-333 NHL fights 57%
15)Marty McSorley-273 NHL fights 56%
16)Dave Richter-62 NHL fights 61%
17)Glen Cochrane-107 NHL fights 59%
18)Bob Gassoff-44 NHL fights 67%
19)Stan Jonathan-84 NHL fights 58%
20)Sandy McCarthy-165 NHL fights 57%
21)Craig Berube-295 NHL fights 56%
22)Nick Fotiu-65 NHL fights 58%
23)Terry O' Reilly-223 NHL fights 54%
24)Stu Grimson-270 NHL fights 54%
25)Garry Howatt-237 NHL fights 54%
There you go boys.
Bible Pimp: " Do you even know how to read my son?"
Bubbles: " Well that depends, do you know how to go f*ck yourself?"