Player
1-Bob Probert
2-Behn Wilson
3-Dave Brown
4-Georges Laraque
5-Jim McKenzie
6-Marty McSorely
7-Donald Brashear
8-Larry Playfair
9-Joe Kocur
10-Sandy McCarthy
11-Craig Berube
12-Tie Domi
13-Clark Gillies
14-Ken Baumgartner
15-Tony Twist
16-Bob Nystrom
17-Stu Grimson
18-Eric Godard
19-Glen Cochrane
20-Dave Schultz
21-Derrek Boogaard
22-John Kordic
23-Dan Maloney
24-Eric Cairns
25-Todd Ewen
That's my current top 25 but this may change, I still have several guys to look at and rate but moving is taking up a lot of my time, packing, cleaning, etc.
My rankings are skill based, for the most part but longevity/number of fights turned out to be an important factor, it helped some guys and hurt others, like Fotiu. Nick just missed the top 25 when at one time he was in my top 10. A couple of guys who may make the top 25 are
Tim Hunter and
Darren Langdon, 2 guys I haven't worked on yet.