One of the few fighters insane enough to go toe-to-toe with Kocur's sledgehammer, Id go slight edge Gaetz in the first fight although he had an immediate advantage having just used his stick to remove Kocur's helmet.
The second fight was one of the most one-sided, brutal beatings Ive ever witnessed in a hockey fight. Credit to Gaetz for staying on his skates, not bailing, and even trying to fight back, but that was as one-sided as it comes. A mastercalss in power-puncing by Kocur.
I read a Gaetz interview a while back, and he said that Joey Kocur
was the toughest man he had ever fought on ice, in any league. And Gaetz played in a whole lot of different leagues.