Here is my list:
Players
Eric Cairns VOL. I, III
Brad May
Chris Gratton
Steve Ott VOL. I
Zdeno Chara Vol. I
Scott Stevens Vol. II
Joe Kocur Vol. II
Shane Churla Vol. II
Mark Tinordi
Brendan Shanahan Vol. II
Darren McCarty Vol. I, II
Brendan Witt Vol. I
Wade Belak Vol. I, II
Derek Boogard 2002-2006
Peter Worrell Vol. II
Derian Hatcher Vol. I
Sean Avery Vol. I
Scott Mellanby
Jeremy Roenick
Chris Chelios
Keith Primeau
Luck Richardson 1986-2000
Eric Lindros Vol. I, II
Boomers
Bob Nystrom
Milan Lucic Vol. I, II
Chris Pronger
Ed Jovanovski
Paul Laus Vol. II
Jordin Tootoo
Eric Godard Vol. II
Bob Probert Vol. IV, V
Chris Neil
PJ Stock Vol. II
Chris Simon Vol. II
Tony Twist Vol. II
Compilations
Goalie Fights Vol. II
NHL Rivalries
Bruise Brothers
Suggs Solid 70's
NHL Line Brawls
Hockey Classics II
Old Scraps
Detroit 1999-2000
Detroit 2002-2004
Detroit vs. Colorado
New York Rangers fights
NHL toe-2-toe
Best Brawls Ever
NHL Various 1965-1975
Toronto vs. Ottawa
Bench clearing brawls Vol. III
Tough Guy Chronicles 1973-1979
Bloody TKO's 1995-1998 (x2)
Vicious 70's
Seasons
Best of 1998-1999 Vol. I, II
Best of 1999-2000 Vol. I, II
Absolute best of 1999-2000
NHL Best of 2000-2001 Vol. I, II, III, IV, V
NHL Best of 2001-2002
NHL Best of 2001-2002 Vol. I, II
NHL Best of 2002-2003
NHL Best of 2003-2004 Vol. I, II, III, IV
NHL Best of 2005-2006 Vol. I (2x), II, III, IV
NHL Best of 2007-2008
NHL Best of 08-09 Vol. I, II
I had a bunch more but lost them to extenuating circumstances, so luckily I have been able to rebuild to this much, before too long I think I am going to get back into it.