View Single Post
  #68 (permalink)  
Old 08-29-2002, 09:02 PM
The Reaper's Avatar
The Reaper The Reaper is offline
Hall of Famer
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: ****ville USA, also known as Gloucester NJ.
Posts: 6,467
Blues 34 Ok, I'll give you my opinion and please don't take any offense. Probert at 1 is a good choice. Kocur over Brown is insane IMO because Kocur has alot of nobodies on his card. A great enforcer he was, but not even close to Brown IMO. Twist and Grimsom are OK I guess, but Twist had alot of nothing wins and Grimson was horrible at the start. McSorely and Kordic were clearly better enforcers IMO. If you are considering primes with McCarthy and Simon, I have no problem with them. As you may know, I take the whole career into account, but many consider just primes so to each his own. Hopefully, you will be able to get ahold of some old timers footage and compare on what you see rather than what you hear. I remember my all time list did'nt differ much from yours before I got my hands on alot of the older guy's footage so don't think I'm insulting you.
Reply With Quote