I'd call it a draw, but Richards loses points for hitting a downed opponent. Must admit, I'm happy with ANYONE that wipes that smarmy grin off of Richards' egotistical face. (Richards tried to blind-side hit Cooke last game, then wouldn't fight him. )
It always makes me laugh when a Flyer fan complains about someone being cheap or dirty. As I recall thats the only way that worthless franchise ever even won a cup. Good fight between two agitators, give the edge to Cooke for the late cheap shots from Bichards.
Doing something classless to a classless player still makes it classless. Mike Richards failed to beat him fair so he goes dirty to try and get the win. Win Cooke because he landed the better blows while both were on their skates.