Derek Boogaard vs Colton Orr

Orr is a demonitorr.

I wonder if Orr has a concussion? anyway the man is tough...but I say he tackled Boogey to avoid the damage that was coming from one or two more sledge hammers. Tackle = win for Boogeyman.

Boogaard win
Orr just trying to hang in there...on the end of Boogaards extended arm.
Lucky take down but that doesn't signify a win.

Pretty even fight would like to see a rematch but with boogaards injury issues i dont think that will happen this season. Boogaard has seemed to have issues staying healthy as of late.

mishaps don't happen twice..

Considering the size difference, and the face that Colton Orr was the one who instigated the fight, and also controlled the fight.

He, is the winner.

two respected fighters in the nhl! god bless boogaard !!!

Boogaard landed. Orr didn't. Edge Big B

I am not a fan of either team but this seems like a clear draw. Orr does give up reach and still was able to handle himself extremely well. Boogard does well against the other huge players in the league so I would rate him at the top or right next to it.

when was the last time somebody got take down against boogaard?draw

Orr with a couple early, Boogie with a couple in the middle, draw

Orr with the take down. Didn't seem to suffer any ill effects from his previous KO. The Dude has a serious set of NUTS don't he?

draw!!

Decent fight, but sooner or later (probably sooner judging by his recent fights) Orr will be seriously tagged by his opponent. He leaves himself wide open to haymakers. Admittedly, his fights are usually entertaining, but does he think that's worth getting helped off the ice like Ivanans?

Nice win Orr. Landed more, got the take down