Matt Carkner vs Trevor Gillies

Decent scrap. Too close to call. Draw.

carkner landed good uppercuts at the start and more punches all together thats why he gets the win. just cause someone gets slung to the ice doesnt make that person a loser. in my opinion its a ***** move to sling someone to the ground cuz you have no other way of winning the fight

i thought Carkner was more active, he got rag-dolled at the end but I thought he threw more...

I would say Carkner 'landed' the harder shots, Gillies with the take down, even though there was blood it wasn't a face cut.... so DRAW, nice tilt

terrible announcers by the way....

Gillies has been a beast since the islanders brought him up. hasn't lost yet. Carkner is a hard throwing S.O.B too.

Trevor kept Carkner at Bay....no cleaar winner...I will give the Decission to Gillies because of the great Mustache.....It's great to see a Gillies in the Islander line-up again....CG #9.....one tuff SOB

Neither one of these clowns needed to ever set foot in the NHL. That said, Gillies is far and away the superior fighter...and it shows here.

Evenly matched and even fight...called it a draw.

Trev gave that bitch ass punk the ass whooping her deserved for cheap shotting Jackman

gillies i dont like carkner

gillies 'stached him. good fight.

Good fight edge Gillies

Gillies is one tough SOB. Payback is a Bitch. (Cartner's cheap shot on Jackman) *** Carkner, Cut, Bloodied, and whipped to the ice like a rag doll. Gillies not even breathing heavy. Win goes to Trevor. Is it coincidence that the Isles are playing better now that Gillies has their backs?

gillies landed the best shots and bloodied him. win gillies!

Gillies with the slight edge for the bloodshow.

Ruutu is such a gutless piece of ****. He and Carcillo should fight each other. It'd be an epic ***** fight since they both prefer to take on non-fighting skill guys.