Matt Carkner vs Donald Brashear

Embarrassed by round one, Brashear attempts a redemption rematch...
and is, soundly, punched to the ice for his efforts.
As Neil Young once said...
''It's better to burn out, than it is to rust''.

Carkner has made a big statement by beating Orr and now Brashear.. a candidate for Rookie of the year !

KD win Carkner.....nice job slats way to bring a washed up Brash to New York and let Orr go??

Man I just HATE Brash!!!!! Givein it to Road Island Red!!!!!

win carkner....brash not what he used to be..or maybe not motivated anymore

W Carkner

Brashear keeps doing it, but Carkner won with a huge punch. I agree with anyone who thinks losing Orr (Colton not Bobbie) was a mistake for the Rangers.

Didn't you used to be Donald Brashear? Win Carkner!

I'll never get tired of seeing Brashear getting dropped. I just hope he stays in the league long enough for everyone to enjoy it over and over for years to come.

Well, I'm finally going to have to make a decision. Is Carkner, for whom I've never had any respect , actually a damn good fighter? Or is Brash, who I don't like but have not been ready to write off, finally on a very steep down turn? I'll go with both options. Clear win for Carkner

Win Carkner by a slight edge due to power punch. Brash had quick jabs but dont hurt to bad. still too much hugging by brash

I hate the sens, but you gotta love Carkner, he continues to impress.

huge bomb

Nothing worse than seeing that washed up used car salesman of a brashear keep hanging on to the nhl to support his blow habit - pathetic that the nhl allows it. It isn't even worth seeing him get his head pounded in anymore.

Carkner took it to him... Brashears hug fest didnt didnt it for him this time..