Brian Sutherby vs Jay McKee

Great hit. McKee is not a fighter and that fight was so unnecessary that I can't call a winner out of principle. Draw and a 1.

monster hit. sutherby gets a w. but that hit was friggin awsome.

Sutherby with CLEAR WIn

once again a clean hit and there has to be a fight what garbage.
parrish should have kept his head up and he wouldnt have gotten drilled the way he did.

Sutherby wins the fight easily, but a great open ice check by McKee. Still don't understand why players always feel the need to start a fight on hard clean checks. You want pay back? Throw a big check of your own....

I'm glad Sutherby got in there - especially after that reckless pass he had just made. I know he didn't mean to turn Parish into a sitting duck like that, but after watching the replay I'm really not sure why Sutherby made the pass. He had time, space and no one had a good angle on him; plus McKee was sitting there licking his chops. Sutherby looked like a never-ever beer league player who is afraid to touch the puck. The least he could do is try to make up for it by dropping the gloves.

slight edge to sutherby, the general managers, and the stooge commishiner should pull their collective heads out of their asses, unless they want to lose half their fan base with all this talk about banning fighting.

not much going on in this fight.

A CLEAN HIT???? Are those homer St. Louis commentators completely retarded?? McKee left his feet and took a classless run at a clean veteran player. Mark Parrish. Then McKee just hangs on when Sutherby comes knocking. Then Sutherby gets an instigator for sticking up for his teammate. Another perfect example of what's wrong with the NHL. What has happened to the game we all used to love?? Thank you again Gary!!!!!!

This is gay, fight after a clean hit. If Scott Stevens was still in the game he'd be fighting every night. These teams must be watching Oilers hockey!

Sutherby did what he should have
Mckee with a great but dangerous hit
"Turtle Mckee"

The league is the reason that Sutherby got an instigator penalty. You're going to start seeing more and more of that. The NHL is OK with fights in general but it is starting to penalize players who come in to protect (or respond) to hits like that. It sucks. It's paranoia stemming from the minor leaguer who died earlier this season.

Lets see... McKee makes a great, *clean*, hit on a guy who should have been watching and gets jumped. Nothing wrong there. Who cares. It is a contact sport. But to say Sutherby "won" this non-fight by virtue of throwing two punches to no punches shows the active imagination of Dallas fans. Reminds me of when the Blues Perron got laid out a few weeks ago. Sucked... but then he also should have been looking where he was going. There was some hard feelings after the hit there also but... who cares. Makes for a good game!

Ok i love fights, i dont love retaliation fights on good clean hits that dont injure players but mckee was out to hurt somone bad, i wouldnt call that clean i'd call that a charge. Yeah i love heavy hits, they're great to watch. Sutherby did the right thing if someone did that to my teammate i'd be the first in line to kick the **** out of them, it was a heavy hit but it wasnt completly clean, first time i saw it i thought it was an elbow, it wasnt but he still left his feet to take his head off. i dont know how you can get mad at someone for trying to get back at a guy who tryed to take your teammates head off. This is coming from a blues fan too btw.

Lord, I dislike the Blues announcers. Sutherby was the intermission interviewee and was pretty upset with himself for getting Parrish laid out by a "suicide pass" and said he went after McKee to let Par know the guys are behind him. You could read his lips that he was pissed at himself.

On a fun note (no pun intended) my baby girl was at the game cheering for her hometown Stars. She said the fights were kinda cool.