I'm sorry but I didn't see a fight. Definitely an ugly hit. I have to go with a draw I guess. I can't wait to read the comments in a day or so and read how all the Columbus guys on the ice are lucky that Neil didn't drop his mitts or they would all be headless.
Who in the blazes of jamaican hot sauce went toe to toe here? This was nothing but a scrum. Give Umberger the gate for the hit, (on his former teamate no less) and give out the matching roughing minors (while they're at it throw Jerkko out for existing, although he did the slightly noble thing and came in with the stick to defend his teamate). People told me to rate this fight that wasn't a fight. Now i gotta go sort those people out!