| Date / Time | Away / Home Team | Away / Home Player |
| Jan 28, 2009 | New York Rangers | Colton Orr |
| 1pd 00:03 | Pittsburgh Penguins | Eric Godard |
| You must login to vote. You can sign up for free if you do not have an account already. |
| Eric Godard | 93.0% | |
| Draw | 5.0% | |
| Colton Orr | 2.0% | |
| From 400 votes with an average rating of 7.6 | ||
| AHL | Jan 28, 2005 | 2pd 07:13 | Godard (BRI) | vs | Orr (PRO) | Details |
| NHL | Feb 2, 2006 | 1pd 07:38 | Orr (NYR) | vs | Godard (NYI) | |
| NHL | Mar 29, 2006 | 1pd 03:11 | Orr (NYR) | vs | Godard (NYI) | |
| NHL | Dec 3, 2008 | 1pd 02:46 | Godard (PIT) | vs | Orr (NYR) | |
| NHL | Jan 5, 2009 | 3pd 17:14 | Godard (PIT) | vs | Orr (NYR) | |
| NHL | Mar 28, 2009 | 2pd 02:30 | Orr (NYR) | vs | Godard (PIT) | |
| NHL | Oct 10, 2009 | 1pd 02:19 | Godard (PIT) | vs | Orr (TOR) |

Great fearless exchange of power shots, that was generally even until Goddard popped him down.
He's still the reigning champ, despite this being a close one