| Date / Time | Away / Home Team | Away / Home Player |
| Oct 20, 2003 | Florida Panthers | Lyle Odelein |
| 1pd 16:34 | New York Rangers | Matt Barnaby |
| Comments: This one starts at the same time as Hordi-Simon, but on the opposite side of the ice and the camera doesn't focus on them for a bit. When they do both guys are throwing right hands and spinning. Odelein falls on top at end. | ||
| You must login to vote. You can sign up for free if you do not have an account already. |
| Lyle Odelein | 52.4% | |
| Draw | 28.6% | |
| Matt Barnaby | 19.0% | |
| From 21 votes with an average rating of 5.1 | ||
| 1pd 16:34 | Darcy Hordichuk | vs | Chris Simon | Details |
| 2pd 14:28 | Andreas Lilja | vs | Chris Simon | Details |
| 2pd 14:28 | Nathan Horton | vs | Vladimir Malakhov | Details |
| 3pd 20:00 | Gregory Campbell | vs | Dan LaCouture | Details |
| NHL | Oct 09, 1993 | 3pd 18:38 | Barnaby (BUF) | vs | Odelein (MON) | Details |
| NHL | Dec 31, 1996 | 2pd 20:00 | Odelein (NJD) | vs | Barnaby (BUF) | Details |
| NHL | Apr 15, 1998 | 3pd 17:29 | Barnaby (BUF) | vs | Odelein (NJD) | Details |
| NHL | Dec 26, 1998 | 1pd 07:27 | Barnaby (BUF) | vs | Odelein (NJD) | Details |
| NHL | Dec 26, 1998 | 1pd 13:26 | Barnaby (BUF) | vs | Odelein (NJD) | Details |
| NHL | Jan 13, 2006 | 2pd 15:08 | Odelein (PIT) | vs | Barnaby (CHI) | Details |
Barnaby did well but got EDGED by Odie.