Wade Redden vs Ryan Whitney

Whitney absolutely dominated Redden in this one. Like others have asked....how could ANYONE vote for Redden....did he even attempt a punch?

Good scrap... Whitney sticks up for his team's star and Redden doesn't back down when he knows he has to fight. Clear win Whitney.... If there was no instigator penalty Crosby wouldn't have to worry about getting hacked like that... BJL would go after ne one who got cheap with him.

On a side note, inspired by ROCKHAWKs' continuous homophobic comments, I have taken it upon myself to devise a 5 point scale, in which we may now rate the less than stellar fights..........by gayness!

1. Sloppy Tonguekiss
2. Groping Hugfest
3. HJ with a Happy Ending
4. Dirty Sanchez with a reach around
5. Totally ROCKHAWKED!

Redden was #4

well as a minny fan i guess im suppose to hate pit for what they did in 91'
but unlike 80% of people on here they dont vote with their eyes! i give the win toooooooo Ryan Whitney! and why is Cote even brought up in this? why is philly fans talking trash? Shouldnt you guys worry about #8 on Wash? PLEASE judge the fights the way they should be, not the way you want them to be!!!!!!!

Penguinsfan123, Whats hilarious is before the last game you guys only won that because the NHL is blowing Sidney Crosby. The refs made 2 horrible calls, and missed one call that would of put us on a 4 min power play. I think the season series was 5-3 flyers? Yea thats right prick. You call cote a fake heavyweight, its kinda sad that you think that when BGL said "he is the toughest guy pound for pound". If cote was a "Fake Heavweight" then he shouldnt be winning fights against heavyweights. Good try clown on talking smack. Any other pens fans want to try?

win Whitney

Wit steppin in for the young captain..and if any of yinz heard that jaggoff sports columnist from the ottawa sun don somethin, sayin something along the lines of Slash crosby ankle like a bunch of goons that make the sport hard for super talents to strive. Or laraque calling him stupid, this sports writer called georges to say it to his face...enough said.
how does that fine from the NHL feel Redden?....

I'm a sens fan and I have to say I'm suprised this fight was 100% Whitney. Sidney proves that he is the cry baby players claim him to be, starting **** and waiting for someone else to finish it.

And what's with Neil making love to Crosby there while someone on his team is gettin a **** kickin?!?!?!?!?!??!?!?!?!?!?

I hope next time he comes to his senses and either fights Whitney (or whoever) himself or at least throws Sid the cry baby around. Ridiculous...

Redden is brutal. This dumb-assed COKEHEAD sucks and has been dragging this team down for years. NOONE in the league should be afraid of this doucebag. he even tried the "C'mon" wave to Whitney. then gets his ass handed to him. his hands are open and throwing slaps. then his fingernail or something cuts Whitney. and he's usually to blame for the turnovers and bad passes. what a loser. can't wait for this guy to leave so onother team can pay for his drugs. and his buddy Emery.

Whitney whipped some Ass!!

Murdamore you are a ******. I guess that Gonchar didn't cut Hartnell. Hartnell must have faked that cheep shot. I guess you can't just like the Pens without hateing the Flyers.

You are an a**hole. Go Ottawa

It takes both Redden and Neil to gang up on Crosby. Couple of real men there. Good for Whitney for pounding on that jerk Redden. Maybe in this series there's some more missing teeth for Neil in the picture.

I can not believe the hating going on against the Pens. Ovechkin the best??? At what propping up his recliner??? Changing the channels?? Best hockey player at golf??? Cause those are all of the things he is doing now. If he was the best his team would have pulled that game out. But they or he didn't. It should have been his overtime goal to take the caps on to the next but he didnt. So the Pens are still in. The protect their stars and the swept Ottawa. Quit hatin' on the Pens. Hatcher isn't going to do **** to Sidney because his old ass will get dealt with. Philly is going to get beat regardless of who the play next round. The just are not that good. Pgh will beat the Rangers in 6 and move on to the next. Suck it up all you haters. Could someone tell me the last time Philadelphia won a Championship in anything? Anyone. Go Flames LOL You mean go home Flames. cause that were they are heading LOL

Nice to see Whitney come to Crosby's defence. Redden deserved what he got.

penguins, most over rated, crosby will disappear faster than lindros, why is it that penguin fans are so arrogant with how good they think their team is, from out of business to the greatest team ever, and it only took how many lottery picks, hopefully they meet the flyers so that the flyers will beat them just like the regular season