Donovan vs McCabe

McCabe with the slight win as he landed more.
Seems to me that McCabe is even a rusty for the fighter as you know that Donovan isn't a fighter.
But McCabe was slightly better as he gets top of Donovan, landing a couple.

Is Mccabe getting voted the winner because he broke the code and punched when they were on the ice. When the actual fight is happening (not the gutless ending) donovan actually seems to be the aggressor.

Kind of a not much going on scrap that stayed pretty even throughout.
When did Donovan become a tough wanna be. Tell me this isn't Batgirl to Neils' Robin and McGrattons' Batman...this could get ugly fast as soon as the first real middleweight, or Catwoman, shows up.

McCabe didn't do anything until they fell down. Then as a true Leaf (who missed the playoffs again) he threw a couple.

Donovan let him up and McCabe punched him while he was down. Nice.

McCabe should do more of this. Once upon a time he used to fight and was quite good. He also used to hit and score and now he does very little. It seems to me he stopped fighting after Chara tossed him around in a fight a few years back. Chara didn't really hurt him, but I guess it embarassed him or something because he hasn't fought since unless another player starts throwing punches at him like Donovan did in this fight and he has no choice but to fight back. McCabe got the contract he got because he was coming off a season where he was probably the best point man on the power play in the league. However, things haven't gone that well for him since. That's why the Leafs would love to get rid of him.

Donovan started the fight and was throwing punches before McCabe even knew he was in a fight. Why are people on here complaining about McCabe throwing punches at Donovan when he was down. Donovan didn't follow the code to begin with so you can't expect McCabe to. If it were me I would have kept pounding Donovan while he was down until the refs dragged me off.

Nobody won that lame scrap, but I voted Donovan to even it up... obviously too many Toronto fans on here with rose-coloured glasses.

-Vancouver fan

Donnovan threw him around like a rag doll chara style.. Leafs can't fight or win..

TORONTO !!!!!

BRYAN MCCABE !!!!

LETS GO LEAFS !!!!

Donovan owns Mccabe. McCabe even tried running away like a *****.

McCabe is a beeotch !!!

This bout started because of the earlier hit that Bell put on Alfie. Bell layed Alfie the **** out. 'mikefisher12' is obviously upset that Fisher and Alfie will be out IF the gay sens even make the playoffs. and yes McCabe lost to Chara, much like EVERYONE that has ever faught him. But its things like willing to fight Chara that gets him paid 5 mill. 'mikefisher12' great start to the season too bad you'll be out 1st round if you even make it. Loser. and maybe the Leafs didnt make the playoffs, but if we did we'd knock the sens out like we do every time, homos.

GO LEAFS GO

Donovan let's him up when he could have threw a cheap shot, but McCabe tosses a couple cheapies at the end with Donovan down. One of the richest teams in the league, one of the biggest bunch of losing whiners ever. McCabe sucks pitty the team the leafs unload him on this summer.

McCabe once again that he is the most fake ass tough guy wannabe in the NHL. Has this guy ever won a fight against anyone that isn't a super lightweight.....I mean come on, getting thrown down by Shean Donovan? As he is a useless tit defensively, I fail to see why this guy makes upwards of $5 million a year. He puts pucks into his own net and gets beat down on a consistent basis. If any of you want a good laugh, watch the clips of McCabe vs Chara from a few years ago. Classic McCabe.

the same amount of punches and McCabe gets knocked down twice. he ends on top and that's a win? and he was trying to get away from Donovan.

it's a fight not a wrestling match. there's no 3 count or shoulders touching rule. vote on when they are still standing.