Ryan Whitney vs Jeff Carter

jeff carter is my man

whitney isnt a fighter but at least he tried, i give this one to carter, hands down

obvoiusly BradE13Pens your a bitch. you a pathetic person for even thinking the penguins are good. OOO crosby and malkin!!! without them you would have no team. hey maybe if we finsih last every year and get consecutive first picks we can just rebiuld our ****ty team too. you garbage, the penguins are garbage and eager was a joke. he couldnt even win a fight thus we traded him and now we have the most dominating line of RW arron asham, LW josh Gratton and C riley cote. so now you penguins *****s can cry and dive just like crosby. **** YOU PENGUINS SUCK o and richards will be MVP this year so suck a fat one crosby/ malkin

Should lose the visor, but it looked like it was far enough back before they started throwing for it not to block his face.

carter all the way. not really close.

carter connected with more, especially since whitney lost his helmet, carter wins

the only reason carter doesnt get it is the freakin shield. gotta take off the shield. and i live IN PHILLY
oh and BRADE 13 pens, your a bitch.
keystone street 19135 bitch anytime

Holy crap. When did Jeff Carter learn to be physical?

Absolutely owned Whitney. I was surprised, as I'm sure Ray Whitney was, too. I thought Sami Kapanen could probably hold his own better than Jeff Carter, but Carter did a real nice job there.

Carter wins hands down or should I say fists up. Good performance for first time without the gloves.

Pens are a bunch of little babies. Running the goalie because they are losing...give me a break. And what's the deal with Cindy crosby? I'm surprised the tears don't freeze on his face with all the crying he does.

2 sissies wins by Carter and Hartnell who are affraid to lose their helmet with their precious visor...

Philly = dumb ass

Win Carter.
Pens doing there normal stuff, losing by a bunch because they suck then they play like little kids. hitting people for not reason, taking dumb pentalys, and GBL is a joke. He had no reason to run into Biron at the end of the game. and he trys to fight Eager on the ground. if your gonna drop the gloves make sure the other player does too.

The Flyers, Kicking ass and taking names.

seriously...you're bitching about his visor? Whitney throws the first punch. Its not like they squared off, it just sort of happend. What is supposed to do, ask whitney to stop so he can take it off? You're right it wasn't square off the bat, whitney started throwing punches before carters' gloves come off. But carter battled back. I look forward to the next game.

I give this a draw, because how many guys does it take to fight Whitney. I don't understand how there wasn't a second man in game misconduct on Coburn (I think) What a bum. So draw. I think Carter would have taken him anyway, but I almost call it a disqualification.

Whose The B.itch That Grabbed Whitney From Behind There Then Fell. Kind Of Hard To Fight Back Against Carter When Someone Else Has Ahold Of U.