Ryan Whitney vs Jeff Carter

carter connected with more, especially since whitney lost his helmet, carter wins

Holy crap. When did Jeff Carter learn to be physical?

Absolutely owned Whitney. I was surprised, as I'm sure Ray Whitney was, too. I thought Sami Kapanen could probably hold his own better than Jeff Carter, but Carter did a real nice job there.

Carter wins hands down or should I say fists up. Good performance for first time without the gloves.

slight edge to carter but it wasnt a good fight

2 sissies wins by Carter and Hartnell who are affraid to lose their helmet with their precious visor...

Philly = dumb ass

seriously...you're bitching about his visor? Whitney throws the first punch. Its not like they squared off, it just sort of happend. What is supposed to do, ask whitney to stop so he can take it off? You're right it wasn't square off the bat, whitney started throwing punches before carters' gloves come off. But carter battled back. I look forward to the next game.

Win Carter.
Pens doing there normal stuff, losing by a bunch because they suck then they play like little kids. hitting people for not reason, taking dumb pentalys, and GBL is a joke. He had no reason to run into Biron at the end of the game. and he trys to fight Eager on the ground. if your gonna drop the gloves make sure the other player does too.

The Flyers, Kicking ass and taking names.

I got beat up by Jeff Carter , boy am I a puss ! What a victory , Pens are the wussiest team in the NHL ! Oh , and your goalies still suck !!!!!!!!!!!!

wow, talk about a couple of non-fighters.....and it showed. still, edge goes to Carter

Whose The B.itch That Grabbed Whitney From Behind There Then Fell. Kind Of Hard To Fight Back Against Carter When Someone Else Has Ahold Of U.

I give this a draw, because how many guys does it take to fight Whitney. I don't understand how there wasn't a second man in game misconduct on Coburn (I think) What a bum. So draw. I think Carter would have taken him anyway, but I almost call it a disqualification.

ok fight, but flyers 2 big boys got smacked around pretty bad!
great to see the rivelry back!

is a win from behing a visor really a win. lame.

PHILLY SUCKs but Carter gets the win. He tuned that herb Whitney up. I would never drop the gloves again if I was him.

Good win by Carter, Whitney should keep his gloves on, he got destroyed by a player that doesn't even fight.