I don't think this one was very close at all. Looks like Orr bloodied him, but hard to tell. At the very least, Shelley's face was pretty red from some of those solid shots he took. Props to him for toughness and taking a punch, or 6, in the face.
Shelley taps Orr with the stick, they drop the gloves and go. Orr gets in a few quick rights which seem to stun Shelley. Shelley gets in some shots of his own Orr gets in a few more, they seem to tire, the linesmen step in, break it up. Shelley is bloodied around the bridge of the nose. A very good fight with lots of punches by both. Winner: Colton Orr