Scott Hartnell vs Troy Brouwer

Agree with Spartan7 entirely. Hartnell win.

Oh so, since he stayed..UPRIGHT....he won. They're on ICE. They are FIGHTING. ON ICE. They're GONNA FALL......Hartnell wins in my book. 4 clean hits vs 1 sissy retreat punch.

Hartnell landed a nice one. then he fell down. hartnell won imo

edge brouwer....brouwer with good clean hit on G but scottie didn't like it.

And Brouwer won how? he pushed Hartnell down and because its Hartnell he falls like a two year old girl and the win goes to Brouwer? Hartnell takes this, he landed the punches and if he had a little bit of balance would have pound this fool.

Wasnt a fight

Has there ever been a player other than Hairball whose sudden absence of balance mysteriously occurs only when he fights a non-threatening European ?

Hartnell landed punches, Brouwer did not.

The filthadelphia fans voted for "The cowardly lion"??? He didn't even get a punch in!? hahahah
Win- Brouwer

I swear if there is anyone you want to fight in the NHL it is Hartnell, that guy is the biggest b++ch I have ever seen. He has never won a fight in his life, I would love to fight him. Hahaha. Crappy fight,

Hartnell early on points with a few rights. But then he loses said points by falling over. Draw

Hartnall plays edgy on the cheap side,not a fan for sure,glad they took helmuts off!! Brouwer wins cause he landed on top,with what looked to be the only punch that counted!

Hartnell with a close win..pummelled Brouwer early then lost his balance. If he stays on his feet, its not even close

"Clean" hit by today's standards, ever since boarding stopped being an infraction.

Anyway, not much followed. Brouwer get the (weak) win because staying upright during the fight still counts for something.

I noticed hartnell always goes down backward, i'm starting to think its his hair pulling him backwards