Robyn Regehr vs Brandon Segal

Slight edge Regher in this retaliatory, non-event...
but I'm siding with Starsfan71's theory on the hit, itself.

It's hard to say who's the perp in this one. You watch the replay and it appears that Segal was going for the check but I doubt he had malice on his mind. Why would he take a dumb penalty with his team up by just one goal they had scored only a couple minutes earlier?

I usually am not a big fan of punching when they are down, but when it is a knee on knee, all rules go out the window. I also don't like to see every hit result in someone having to defend himself after a body check, but again it was knee on knee, so I don't blame Regehr one bit. I don't think it was intentional, but when it happens that fast, someone is going to flip as we are talking about season ending injuries.

You can have incidental contact. The puck carrier makes a little move and the Dallas guy starts to pull up then the collide. I say it happened too fast to have a contentious effort to go knee to knee. Go back and look at a Bryan Marchment knee to knee.

Steven Segal is not Above the Law.....win R&R

Robyn landed the only shots

Baldy gets into his 2nd scrap in just as many games.

Stajan really has to be more careful in the trolly tracks. He's done this a few times this year.

Regehr with CLEAR win
he had clear control and landed only blows

We really couldn't expect a decent scrap between these two punks who don't know how to fight, and they proved us correct...

Draw, Segal was tired and nothing was really done. I'm very much against punches thrown when you're on the ice though.

Regehr is edgy these days, Knee on Knee can be a career killer. Segal's knee had to be hurting too, but you should be held responsible for your play. There has to be other checks you can throw there.

Nothing fight from a nothing hit..meh

Hey dumbass, neither player was looking at the other when they collided. It happens.

Not sure if that one is Segal's fault or Stajan's fault.

Hey boneheads, look at the collision. Both players are turning left when they hit, which will always put your feet across the other's path. Segal was going for the hit, Stajan tried to avoid it by jumping and it's a good thing, probably avoided a knee injury. But it also made it look worse than it was when he went ass over elbows. Neither of these players are dirty players but you just gotta come back after a spectacular-looking hit and stand up for your teammate. Regehr, just on the ice, did that despite his age and did well against someone who would lump him up if Segal wasn't at the end of a long shift. Win to Regehr of course, but there's nothing sinister here. You drama queens need to get a life.